Smilin’ Through (Judy Garland – The Singles Collection) available this week from Worlds Records

Posted by

Judy Garland - Smilin' Through - The Singles CollectionThe JSP Records 4-CD deluxe boxed set “Judy Garland – Smilin’ Through – The Singles Collection 1936-1947” is available this week in the U.S. from Worlds Records (it will be available in the U.K. on September 5th).

As noted before, this is the first comprehensive anthology of Judy’s Decca catalog in almost 20 years.  All of Judy’s Decca singles are here, including seven never before released on CD.  ALL have been restored and remastered and they sound better than ever!

For details about the set, check out The Judy Garland Online Discography.  Also of interest is a wonderful article over at The Second Disc (this blog is highly recommended).

NEWS:  After this set went into production, the International Bing Crosby Club came out with the revelation that there is a C take of “Mine” plus a “B” take of “Yah-Ta-Ta,” both duets with Bing Crosby.  This new JSP set already includes the extra T take of “Yah-Ta-Ta” but the fact that there are two more alternate takes is wonderful news!  It’s also puzzling that none of the Garland “experts” out there was aware of these alternates – until now.

These alternate tracks can be found on the Jonzo Records series The Chronological Bing Crosby.  The three takes of “Yah-Ta-Ta” can are on Volume 38, and the two takes of “Mine” are on Volume 37.  All Jonzo/Crosby CDs can be ordered for $20 by calling Wig Wiggins, who heads the International Bing Crosby Club, at (703) 241-5608.

Per the CD set’s compiler and annotator, Lawrence Schulman:  “I have just today [August 6, 2011] discovered the existence of an additional alternate of “Yah-Ta-Ta, Yah-Ta-Ta (Talk, Talk, Talk) and one of “Mine.” Since these discoveries were made after the preparation of Judy Garland: Smilin’ Through – The Singles Collection 1936-1947, they are obviously not included in the new JSP set. As much as it is regrettable that the new release is thus not a complete Garland at Decca, I think it is best to rejoice in the discovery of two hidden tracks. I think as much as I am disappointed that I was not able to include these newly discovered tracks (at least to me), I am also happy that new discoveries continue to be made. I hope there will be many more.”

Download the additional “C Take” of “Mine” here.
Download the additional “B Take” of Yah-Ta-Ta” here. 

It’s pretty amazing that after all these years, previously unreleased Garland performances are still being discovered and shared with the public.  Let’s hope this continues to be the case!


  1. It is amazing how these things turn up every now and again…I love it. Thanks for the news scott. I have placed my order and I can’t wait!

  2. I have the old box set of Judy Garland Decca recordings, but this set looks really good especially if they improved the sound. Thanks for all the emails and updates on Judy. I can’t get enough.

    Take care,

    Richard Mentz

  3. I am playing the new Sinlges Collection. The packaging and sound quaility are wonderful. I only have a question about the Liner Notes to pose to the group.

    The liner notes in the CD A and CD B…the Liner Notes are the same. CD C and CD D are different than the first 2 Liner Notes.

    Are the CD A and CD B Liner Noted supposed to be the same or did I get a mis-print?

    1. Hi James,

      The factory that did the first pressing mistakenly put the opening notes of CD A in CD B too. I immediately noticed this, and informed JSP, which has already corrected the error, and ordered a new pressing, this time corrected. Anyone who has received a set which contains the repeated notes can simply write to John Stedman at for a free copy of brochure B notes. I regret this error, which is the pressing plant’s and not JSP’s, but it was dealt with swiftly. All future orders will have the complete liner notes. I appreciate that people who have purchased the set are kind enough to read the notes – and notice this inadvertent error.

      All best.

      1. P.S. – The notes are a continuum. Thus the notes in CD B follow the ones in A, the ones in D follow C. It is all one text.

  4. Thank you so much for providing links to download the alternates to “Mine” and “Yah-Ta-Ta.” It is wonderful to have them. I’m curious, however, about your statement: “It’s also puzzling that none of the Garland ‘experts’ out there was aware of these alternates – until now.”

    The booklet that came with the Complete Decca Masters collection states that the transcription discs “often preserved numerous takes other than the master. The most interesting of those surviving alternate performances are presented in this collection.” I interpret this to mean there were still many unreleased alternate takes for many of the Decca recordings that just weren’t released. (But maybe I was reading too much into this?) Has anybody checked with the original compilers of the Complete Decca Masters to see exactly what alternate takes they found in the vaults? Perhaps they were aware of these two alternates and chose not to include them in their set.

    1. When Ron O’Brien compiled “The Complete Decca Masters (plus)” back in 1994, he included as many alternates as space would permit. This does not mean he took all the alternates in the Decca vaults. Judy did a few takes of each song, and often there is very little difference between the master and alternate(s). The best take would be chosen as the master, and the others labeled B or C take. If you count the number of songs Judy recorded for Decca, and multiply that by, let us say, three, you can see how many masters and alternates there are. O’Brien chose what space allowed, but never pretended to include all that is out there. As of today, there is no accurate information as to how many alternates exist for each song, so to try to do a complete Judy Garland at Decca is a lost cause. What we have today is a combination of sources, and the O’Brien set is only one. Many alternates were inadvertently released over the years on LP, and these have been included. In the brochure, I give a history of these accidental finds over the years. Not included are the recently unearthed “Mine” and “Yah-Ta-Ta.” So, it is very possible there will be future finds, which would be wonderful. All new finds are a reason to rejoice, but the JSP set is as close as it comes to the complete Decca recordings as of 2011.


      1. The set is wonderful! I received mine a few days ago and after listening several times I wrote a review of the set on Thanks for another great Garland collection! And as always, The Judy Room is the prime place to check out what’s new. Thanks Scott!

        1. Hi Bruce,

          Thanks so much for your kind words, here and on Amazon. The lesson to be learned is that there are no experts, and when in doubt, email anyone and everyone to let them know your thoughts. I especially appreciate your enthusiasm concerning the sound. The JSP set Judy Garland – The Carnegie Hall Concert is already remastered, and ready to be pressed and released early next year, and I am sure you will not be disappointed by the leaps and bounds that have been made sound-wise. Again, a sincere thank you.

          All best.

Leave a Reply to Lawrence Schulman Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.