The long-awaited sequel to 2010’s groundbreaking 4-CD set “Judy Garland Lost Tracks: 1929-1959,” JSP Records’ “Judy Garland Lost Tracks 2 – 1936-1967“ features a whopping 40 new-to-CD tracks. In the years between the two releases many new, previously unreleased and/or thought-lost Garland recordings have been discovered. Also during that time, audio restoration software has advanced to the point that, as in the capable hands of audio engineer John H. Haley, “old” recordings can now sound better than ever thought possible.
Produced, as was the first edition, by John Stedman, and compiled by Lawrence Schulman, this set features many previously unreleased and new-to-CD radio performances that just a little over a year ago were thought lost. Thanks to the generosity of John Newton (his collection is the source of most of the radio tracks) we’re able to enjoy these performances. And amazing they are! Rounding out the collection are several live performances, outtakes, alternate takes, and rehearsals. They all make for a great listening experience.
There is something here for everyone. Fans of Judy’s early years will enjoy the many rare radio recordings. Fans of Judy’s films will enjoy the outtakes, alternates, and extended takes of some of her most popular movie songs. Fans of Judy’s later years will enjoy the concert, studio, and television performances most of which are also making their CD debuts on this set.
Purchase from Amazon UK here.
Purchase from Amazon US here.
Every track here is a treasure (I’m biased, of course, because I think all of Garland’s recordings are treasures), but here are details on some of the highlights:
The transcription disc labels above are from The John Newton Collection. Thanks, John!
Hold That Bulldog & Pennies From Heaven
Judy barks! Both performances are from Judy’s appearance on Jack Oakie’s College radio show on January 5, 1937. Judy prerecorded “Hold That Bulldog” for 20th Century-Fox in the summer of 1936 for her feature film debut in Pigskin Parade (1936). The number was cut and the footage (if it was filmed) and prerecording are lost. This radio performance is the only extant recording of Garland singing this novelty song and gives us an idea of how it might have been performed in the film. At 14 years old, she handles it like a seasoned professional while putting her unique mark on it. As if that wasn’t enough, Judy encored with a flawless rendition of “Pennies From Heaven” in which she’s given some special material (probably provided by her mentor Roger Edens) that showcases her range of styles including a fun jazzy ending.
The transcription disc labels above are from The John Newton Collection. Thanks, John!
Johnny One Note & Always
Judy’s April 20, 1937, performance of “Johnny One Note” just might be the first nationwide public radio performance of the new, soon-to-be-standard, song by Rodgers and Hart. The song premiered on Broadway on April 14, 1937, in “Babes In Arms” which was just six days prior to this Garland performance on “Jack Oakie’s College” radio show. Cut from (and never recorded for) the 1939 film version of the show starring Judy and Mickey Rooney, she later performed the song as her encore in 1948’s Words and Music. For decades fans wondered what the “Young Judy” version would sound like. Now we know: fantastic!
As an encore, Judy again put her mark on what even then an Irving Berlin chestnut of a standard, “Always.” This is the only known recording of Judy singing the lovely song which Berlin wrote for his wife. The love Berlin had for his wife permeate the lyrics and come through via Judy’s emotional rendition.
(Dear Mr. Gable) You Made Me Love You
This classic Garland performance, recorded on May 7, 1937, for Broadway Melody of 1938, is a welcome addition to any CD set. The version presented here is Take 3 of the song which is a partial alternate without Judy’s spoken recitative (“Aw, gee Mr. Gable”) which was recorded live on the set when the song was filmed. The music that provides the background to that spoken bit is lovely.
The transcription disc labels above are from The John Newton Collection. Thanks, John!
A Shine On Your Shoes
On May 25, 1937, Judy put her unique vocal stamp on this wonderful song predating Fred Astaire’s famous performance of it in the 1953 MGM musical The Bandwagon. This version is decidedly more “jazzy” and brilliantly shows off Judy’s vocal abilities. It’s hard to believe she was only 14-years-old!
Where Are You?
Here is a previously thought lost radio performance from Judy’s appearance on Jack Oakie’s College radio show on June 1, 1937. This is another one of Judy’s “recitative songs” in which she delivers a short monologue in the middle of the song, most likely written by her mentor, Roger Edens.
Swing Low, Sweet Chariot
Here is the complete version of this song from the soundtrack of Everybody Sing. In the film, the song is trimmed. The song was previously thought to have been prerecorded on October 24, 1937, but according to the surviving MGM “Daily Music Report,” it was prerecorded on November 8, 1937. The liner notes for this set were printed before this new information was discovered.
Blue Skies
Here is another rarity, and another previously thought lost performance, this time from Judy’s weekly appearances on “The Pepsodent Show Starring Bob Hope,” on January 16, 1940. It is a delight and the only known recording of Judy singing this Irving Berlin standard. Once again, Judy makes the song her own. Listeners will note that the intro chorus is almost identical (save a few words at the end) to the chorus for “Pennies From Heaven” performed by Judy in 1937 and also included on this set (see the track listing below). This intro is another Roger Edens creation written solely for Judy.
Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas
This alternate prerecording for Meet Me In St. Louis was recorded on December 4, 1943, and makes its CD debut here. I have always preferred this version to the one used in the film, even though both are quite lovely. The differences in the two versions are subtle and an example of how seemingly minor subtleties can make for a different listening experience.
Someone At Last
The soundtrack album to Judy’s film masterpiece A Star Is Born (1954) has never been out of print. Included on that album is her now-famous tour de force “Someone At Last.” In fact, the working title of the number was “tour de force.” The version on this set is the CD debut of an alternate take without the dialog, effects, and studio chorus plus a great ending not heard in the final film or the soundtrack album. Also, there’s no “Wilhelm Scream” effect. Talk about a unique listening experience. Judy’s vocals are front and center, and her full throttle ending is hair-raising. Its deletion from the final film is a puzzle.
Over The Rainbow
It’s hard to believe, but Garland’s famous 1955 television rendition of “Over the Rainbow” from the Ford Star Jubilee special has never been restored and remastered for CD.
Come Rain Or Come Shine
Judy returned to television in 1956 for CBS-TV’s “General Electric Theater.” While some of the performances in the special were prerecorded, Judy sang “Come Rain Or Come Shine” live. The song was fairly new to her repertoire and it became another Garland standard.
Down With Love
Judy’s recordings for Capitol Records are some of her finest, so any new discovery from these sessions is a rare treat. Judy’s talent was so great that even her alternates are worth releasing. Presented here for the first time from the collection of Raphael Geroni is an alternate take of “Down With Love” recorded in 1960 for the classic “That’s Entertainment!” album. For many fans, this is the greatest of all her Capitol albums and with good reason. It’s as perfect as anyone can get on an LP of standards. It also brings to mind the fact that it must have been tough to decide which takes of songs ended up on the final releases of albums.
What Now My Love
At this time in her career, Judy alternated between the concert stage, television, and a few films. More new-to-CD performances from this era are presented, finally remastered after years of floating around collector’s circles. A standout is this previously unreleased rehearsal recording of “What Now My Love?” for Judy’s concert with daughter Liza Minnelli at the London Palladium in 1964. Judy was suffering from vocal issues but that didn’t stop her from giving a great performance, even in rehearsal. For comparison, this is followed by her triumphant rendition of the same song in 1966 on NBC-TV’s “Kraft Music Hall” with full orchestral accompaniment.
I’ll Plant My Own Tree
Judy delivered more than anyone else could have when she recorded the final track on this set. “I’ll Plant My Own Tree” was written for Judy to sing as “Helen Lawson” in the film version of Valley of the Dolls (1967). The song is meant to show off the superstar quality of the character. Sadly, it’s not a good song. Out of context, it could be mistaken for parody. Judy didn’t want to record it, preferring “Get Off Looking Good.” But ever the trouper she recorded it and against the odds she makes it sound better than it is. Only a talent of her caliber could have pulled that off. Garland never completed the film and the song was re-recorded by Margaret Whiting for Susan Hayward (the new “Helen Lawson”) to lip-synch to. A mono version with very bad audio appeared on LP in the late 1970s, and this stereo version has been traded by collectors for several decades. Here it’s finally remastered and presented on CD for the first time.
The MGM playback disc label above is from The John Newton Collection. Thanks, John!
Note that the date on the label is different than the prerecording date.
The label date is the date the disc was made.
The “Trinidad Number” MGM playback disc label above is from The Rick Smith Collection. Thanks, Rick!
DISC ONE:
Track 1:
Norrie Paramor Salute To Judy Garland: The Trolley Song (H. Martin/R. Blane)/For Me And My Gal (G.W. Meyer/E. Leslie/E.R. Goetz)/Over The Rainbow (E.Y. Harburg/H. Arlen)/We’re Off To See The Wizard (E.Y. Harburg/H. Arlen)/It’s A Great Day For The Irish (R. Edens)*
Al and Judy
Columbia/E.M.I. Records Limited
ESG 7757, 45 rpm, Side 2, stereo
Norrie Paramor and His Concert Orchestra
Recorded 1958, Released 1959
Track 2:
Waltz With A Swing/Americana (C. Conrad)*
Every Sunday, MGM
Alternate, Take 6
Culver City, 30 June 1936
World premiered at The Judy Room
Track 3:
Hold That Bulldog (L. Pollack/S.D. Mitchell)*
Jack Oakie’s College, radio, CBS
Hollywood, 5 January 1937
World premiered at The Judy Room
Track 4:
Pennies From Heaven (J. Burke/A. Johnston)*
Jack Oakie’s College, radio, CBS
Hollywood, 5 January 1937
World premiered at The Judy Room
Track 5:
Johnny One Note (L. Hart/R. Rodgers)*
Jack Oakie’s College, radio, CBS
Hollywood, 20 April 1937
World premiered at The Judy Room
Track 6:
Always (I. Berlin)*
Jack Oakie’s College, radio, CBS
Hollywood, 20 April 1937
World premiered at The Judy Room
Track 7:
(Dear Mr. Gable) You Made Me Love You (J. McCarthy/J.V. Monaco/R. Edens)*
Broadway Melody of 1938, MGM
Alternate, Take 3
Culver City, 7 May 1937
Track 8:
A Shine On Your Shoes (A. Schwartz/H. Dietz)*
Jack Oakie’s College, radio, CBS
Hollywood, 25 May 1937
World premiered at The Judy Room
Track 9:
Dinah (S.M. Lewis/J. Young/H. Akst)*
Jack Oakie’s College, radio, CBS
Hollywood, 1 June 1937
Track 10:
Where Are You? (H. Adamson/J. McHugh)*
Jack Oakie’s College, radio, CBS
Hollywood, 1 June 1937
Track 11:
Swing Mr. Mendelssohn (G. Kahn/B. Kaper/W. Jurmann)*
Everybody Sing, MGM
Alternate, Take 6
Culver City, 26 August 1937
Track 12:
Sun Showers (A. Freed/N.H. Brown)
Thoroughbreds Don’t Cry, MGM
Alternate, Take 4
Culver City, 11 September 1937
Track 13:
Got A Pair Of New Shoes (A. Freed/N.H.Brown)*
Thoroughbreds Don’t Cry, MGM
Alternate, Take 6
Culver City, 20 September 1937
Track 14:
Swing Low, Sweet Chariot (Negro spiritual)*
Everybody Sing, MGM
Without dialog overdub
Culver City, 24 October 1937
Track 15:
In Between (R. Edens)*
Love Finds Andy Hardy, MGM
Alternate, Take 4
Culver City, 24 June 1938
Track 16:
Meet The Beat Of My Heart (M. Gordon/H. Revel)*
Love Finds Andy Hardy, MGM
Alternate, Take 9
Culver City, 24 June 1938
Track 17:
Blue Skies (I. Berlin)*
The Pepsodent Show with Bob Hope, radio, NBC
Off-the-air home recording
16 January 1940
Track 18:
I’m Nobody’s Baby (B. Davis/M. Ager/L. Santly)*
Andy Hardy Meets Debutante, MGM
Alternate, Take 8
Culver City, 14 March 1940
Track 19:
I’m Always Chasing Rainbows (J. McCarthy/H. Carroll)*
Ziegfeld Girl,, MGM
Alternate, Take 7
Based on Chopin’s Fantasie Impromptu in C sharp minor
Culver City, 13 November 1940
Track 20:
Minnie From Trinidad (with Tony Martin)(R. Edens)*
Ziegfeld Girl, MGM
Alternate
Culver City, 14 January 1941
Track 21:
America (My Country ‘Tis Of Thee) (S.F. Smith/H.Carey (?))*
Life Begins for Andy Hardy, MGM
Outtake
Culver City, 19 May 1941
Track 22:
Abide With Me (H.F. Lyte/W.H. Monk)*
Life Begins for Andy Hardy, MGM
Outtake, Take 7
Culver City, 4 June 1941
Track 23:
The Rosary (R.C. Rogers/E. Nevin)*
Life Begins for Andy Hardy, MGM
Outtake, Take 3
Culver City, 4 June 1941
Track 24:
Easy To Love (C. Porter)
Life Begins for Andy Hardy, MGM
Outtake
Culver City, 4 June 1941
Track 25:
The Joint Is Really Jumpin’ Down At Carnegie Hall (R. Edens/R. Blane/H. Martin)*
Mail Call #19, CBS
With José Iturbi, piano
9 January 1943
DISC TWO
Track 1:
For Me And My Gal (E. Leslie/E.R. Goetz/G.W. Meyer)*
Mail Call Special #38, CBS
Dedicated to Britain
19 May 1943
Track 2:
The Boy Next Door (H. Martin/R.Blane)*
Meet Me in St. Louis, MGM
Alternate, Take 7
Culver City, 4 December 1943
Track 3:
Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas (H. Martin/R. Blane)*
Meet Me in St. Louis, MGM
Alternate, Take 6
Culver City, 4 December 1943
Track 4:
The Way You Look Tonight (with Bing Crosby)(D. Fields/J. Kern)
The Bakers of America Salute the Armed Forces, NBC
With Bing Crosby
4 June 1944
Track 5:
Mine (with Bing Crosby)(I. Gershwin/G. Gershwin)
Decca Records
Master # L 3486-C/Decca 23804 B, Alternate
With Bing Crosby
Joseph Lilley, conductor
Hollywood, 31 July 1944
Track 6:
The Trolley Song (H. Martin/R. Blane)*
Democratic Committee dinner
Johnny Green, piano
Ambassador Hotel, Los Angeles, 8 October 1944
Track 7:
Yah-Ta-Ta, Yah-Ta-Ta (Talk, Talk, Talk) (with Bing Crosby)(J. Burke/J.V. Heusen)
Decca Records
Master # L 3751-B/Decca 23410, Alternate
With Bing Crosby
Joseph Lilley, conductor
Hollywood, 9 March 1945
Track 8:
How Deep Is The Ocean? (I. Berlin)*
The Danny Kaye Show, radio, CBS
5 October 1945
Track 9:
Johnny One Note (L. Hart/R. Rodgers)*
Kraft Music Hall, radio, NBC
30 September 1948
Track 10:
Wishing (Will Make It So) (B.G. De Sylva)
The Hallmark Playhouse, CBS
Adaptation of “Cinderella”
15 February 1951
From RKO film, Love Affair, 1939
Track 11:
A Pretty Girl Milking Her Cow (Traditional Irish ballad/T. Moore, English version)*
Guest Star, Syndication
U.S. Treasury Department public broadcast
Program # 277
Jack Cathcart & his orchestra
13 June 1952
Track 12:
Judy’s Olio: Opening introduction/You Made Me Love You (J. McCarthy/J.V. Monaco)/For Me And My Gal (E. Leslie/E.R. Goetz/G.W. Meyer)/The Boy Next Door (H. Martin/R. Blane)/The Trolley Song (H. Martin/R. Blane)*
Guest Star, Syndication
U.S. Treasury Department public broadcast
Program #277
Jack Cathcart & his orchestra
13 June 1952
Track 13:
Someone At Last (I. Gershwin/H. Arlen)*
A Star Is Born, Warner Bros.
Complete uncut version with no overdubbed sound effects, dialog or chorus
Alternate ending
Warner Bros. Orchestra
Ray Heindorf, conductor
23 November 1953
Track 14:
My Melancholy Baby (G.A. Norton/E. Burnett)*
A Star Is Born, Warner Bros.
Rehearsal with orchestra
Ray Heindorf, conductor
Circa 1954
Track 15:
Over The Rainbow (E.Y. Harburg/H. Arlen)*
Ford Star Jubilee, CBS-TV
Los Angeles, 24 September 1955, live
Jack Cathcart, conductor
Track 16:
Come Rain Or Come Shine (J. Mercer/H. Arlen)*
General Electric Theatre, CBS-TV
Hollywood, 8 April 1956, live
Nelson Riddle, conductor
Track 17:
Down With Love (E.Y. Harburg/H. Arlen)*
Capitol Records
Master # 33953, Alternate, Take 7
That’s Entertainment! LP
Jack Marshall, conductor
Hollywood, 9 June 1960
Track 18:
Just In Time (B. Comden/A. Green/J. Styne)
Judy Garland, Frank Sinatra & Dean Martin Special, CBS-TV
Burbank, California, Taped 5, 8, 9 January 1962 at NBC-TV, Aired 25 February 1962
Mort Lindsey, conductor
Track 19:
Paris Is A Lonely Town (E.Y. Harburg/H. Arlen)*
Jack Paar Show, NBC-TV
New York, Taped 2 December 1962, Aired 7 December 1962
Track 20:
I Happen To Like New York (C. Porter)
Robert Goulet & Phil Silvers Special, CBS-TV
Mort Lindsey, conductor
New York, Taped 30 January to 3 February 1963, Aired 19 March 1963
Track 21:
Memories Of You (A. Razaf/E. Blake)*
The Judy Garland Show, CBS-TV
Episode # 2
With Count Basie on organ
Mort Lindsey, conductor
Television City, California, Taped 7 July 1963, Aired 10 November 1963
Track 22:
What Now My Love (P. Delanoë/G. Bécaud/C. Sigman)*
Rehearsal for Palladium show
London, 6 or 7 November 1964
Track 23:
What Now My Love (P. Delanoë/G. Bécaud/C. Sigman)
The Kraft Music Hall, NBC-TV
NBC Studios
Brooklyn, Taped 20 February 1966, Aired 28 February 1966
Track 24:
What the World Needs Now (H. David/B. Bacharach)
The Hollywood Palace, ABC-TV
Mitchell Ayres, conductor
Los Angeles, Taped 1 April 1966, Aired 7 May 1966
Track 25:
I’ll Plant My Own Tree (D. Previn/A. Previn)
Valley Of The Dolls, 20th Century Fox
Outtake, stereo
Johnny Williams, conductor
Los Angeles, mid-April 1967
Purchase from Amazon UK here.
Purchase from Amazon US here.
DISC CREDITS
Produced by: John Stedman
Compiled and Discography by: Lawrence Schulman
Sleeve notes by: Scott Brogan
Recording sources: John Newton, Raphael Geroni, Lawrence Schulman, John H. Haley, Scott Brogan, Kim Lundgreen
Transfers: John H. Haley, except “Someone At Last” and “Down With Love” by Raphael Geroni
Restoration and Remastering: John H. Haley at Harmony Restorations LLC, with help from Jamie Howarth at Plangent Processes on “Melancholy Baby”
Design: Andrew Roberts
Photos from the collection of: Lawrence Schulman
Cover photo by Apeda Studio, June 1936, New York
Thanks to: Alain Falasse, David Alp
