Interview with Joe Luft and John Kimble by Bill Biss

Posted by

Judy and I: My Life With Judy Garland

An Interview with Joey Luft and John Kimble

By Bill Biss

Judy 1962 Original charcoal by Bill Biss

One of the most instantly recognizable motion picture stars of all time is Judy Garland as “Dorothy” in The Wizard of Oz. The role would bring her eternal fame and lead to a career that lasted over 30 years. A career encompassing classic film musicals, legendary concerts and a television series that is a time capsule of the finest entertainers ever known in “The Judy Garland Show.”

[photo at right: 1962 Original charcoal by Bill Biss]

Judy and I” was written by her third husband, Sid Luft who is the father of Lorna Luft and Joey Luft; married to Judy Garland for over a decade. Luft had been working on his autobiography of his life and his life with Judy for many years. It is a rare and up-close look at Sid Luft’s life before meeting Garland and most importantly… a loving and true testimony to their marriage and Judy’s career. Discovered after Sid Luft’s passing in 2005 by The Sid Luft Living Trust and Royal Rainbow Productions managed by John Kimble and Joey Luft… They now proudly present the most personal portrait of Judy Garland since Lorna Luft penned “Me and My Shadows” in 1998. In Sid’s own words and memories, Luft was a man who never stopped loving Judy Garland. A man who also made some of her greatest accomplishments come true.

Here, for The Judy Room, Joey Luft and John Kimble share their thoughts on the discovery of Joey’s father’s manuscript, the impact of this book and a little bit of humor inspired by the legendary lady, Judy Garland, herself.

Bill Biss: Sid Luft said in his book, “I’m going to help her.” In “Judy and I” his memories of her are so vivid and wonderfully captured. Other than “Me and My Shadows” by his daughter Lorna Luft, these are some of the most personal reflections of Judy Garland that I’ve ever read.

"Judy and I" book coverJoey Luft: That’s good. That’s good.

Bill Biss: Please share the experience of discovering the manuscript for his book that your dad was never able to publish.

John Kimble: You know Bill, when Joey’s dad passed away, you can imagine that there is 90 years of somebody’s life. So, Joey and I were basically trying to figure out what to do with everything in storage. A lot of it was going through boxes and that. Then, a little over a year ago, we were going through the boxes and found this 673-page Xerox copy of Sid’s story. Nobody knew it was in that box.

Bill Biss: Wow.

John Kimble: Then, with the help of Randy Schmidt and the editor at Chicago Review Press, they were able to piece together the whole story.

Bill Biss: It’s quite a remarkable look at your mom.

Joey Luft: Yes. I know.

Bill Biss: There is also the writing of Judy’s that Sid included in this book. She wrote about her voice being much stronger after resting, after leaving MGM. Sid put Judy’s recorded observations in this book, as well.

John Kimble: She was trying to do her own autobiography. I think Sid had access to that, where he was able to, every once and a while use her own language from that.

Bill Biss: That’s a remarkable aspect to “Judy and I.”

Judy Garland and family in Chelsea, London, 1960 (L-R: Liza Minnelli, Lorna and Joe Luft, Sid Luft, Judy Garland)
Judy Garland and family in Chelsea, London, 1960 (L-R: Liza Minnelli, Lorna and Joe Luft, Sid Luft, Judy Garland)

John Kimble: She occasionally wanted to tell her own story and Sid was there when that was happening.

Bill Biss: I had never read those thoughts before. It was very beautiful to have her thoughts put into the book at certain points. Who titled the chapters? It caught my eye with the chapter called “Lost in the Stars.”

John Kimble: Sid did.

Bill Biss: Oh great… “Lost in the Stars” is one of my very favorite Garland songs. Your mom’s humor is so prevalent in the book. There are several hilarious quotes that Sid remembered her saying. One such instance was when he took her to a Narcotics Anonymous meeting for the first and only time back in the 1950’s. Judy was so turned off by the atmosphere with weird lighting, she said, “It’s enough to make a person want to stay bombed forever!”

Joey Luft: Uh-huh (Laughter). Yep.

Bill Biss: Or when she says, “How about a shower or a shave?” when Judy is pouring sand over your dad’s face at the beach, after discovering him fully clothed and asleep with a fashion model… just before they got married.

Joey Luft: Yeah, I remember reading that (Laughs).

Judy Garland and Sid Luft at the premiere of "A Star Is Born" (1954)
Judy Garland and Sid Luft at the premiere of “A Star Is Born” (1954)

Bill Biss: Those quotes bring to light her great sense of humor. Your father really was her “knight in shining armor.” It’s remarkable after reading the book and remembering when your mom told your dad; “I want to work. I need to work.” During the 1950’s and 1960’s, he went out and made that happen. His “rough and ready” style in life and his writing about this… is just another aspect of why this is such an amazing book.

Joey Luft: I know. I know. I just put out a quote for “Inside Edition” which talked about that. My whole life everybody has written books about my mom and some people never knew her.

John Kimble: I’m sure you got the same experience like I did, as Joey knew his dad and his mother better than anybody. Sid knew Judy better than anybody. To actually be able to tell his story without somebody else writing it or telling a different story… it’s very powerful, I think. I don’t want to speak for Joe but I think it’s his legacy and what he always wanted to do; he’s sincere and he’s so proud.

Bill Biss: You can’t get any closer to a legend and a great woman and entertainer. As Sid Luft said, “My little princess was indeed no ordinary mortal.”

(Laughter from all).

Bill Biss: There is so much more to this book than the certain episodes of her life, which some of the press have used to sensationalize her life with Sid Luft.

John Kimble: I know you can enjoy Judy’s sense of humor and what kind of mother she was to him. It’s a shame people don’t write about that. Kirkus gave the book a really good review and they didn’t sensationalize it. Like you Bill, people who really review books and don’t try to put their own slant or perspective of what it used to be. It’s what Joey likes to talk about.

"One Punch Luft" - early photo of the young Sid Luft
“One Punch Luft” – early photo of the young Sid Luft

Bill Biss: Your dad was a tough man and I think that’s what appealed to your mom.

Joey Luft: I know. Yeah.

Bill Biss: Randy L. Schmidt did a seamless job of taking Sid’s previous interviews and taped recordings into the final two chapters.

John Kimble: Yes, Randy had some interviews and then some transcripts that we had. He went around and did his best to not use his own words but what Sid would say. He wanted to finish the story. After Judy and Sid were having trouble… she got involved with a couple of agents. When it got to that part. It was whenever Sid wanted to tell that story. By that time, it’s kind of like what’s happening in the world today with these politics. They keep lying and lying and lying. People start to believe the lie. That’s how that worked with them [David Begelman and Freddie Fields]. There are just these constant lies about Judy and Sid. It was tough because Sid was trying to raise Lorna and Joey, while all that stuff was going on. Joey’s kind of wanted to be able to tell that part of the story about really what happened. Since those guys were still alive at that time, nobody really wanted to write it or tell the story.

Bill Biss: Yes.

John Kimble: For me and for Joe; it’s a bittersweet moment, too, that Sid got in what he was trying to say. To let people come up with their own conclusion based on not everybody else’s stories. It is Sid’s own story. Joey has gotten some feedback that some people didn’t know that side of Sid and it’s kind of cool.

April 21, 1952: Judy arrives at the star-studded post-party celebrating her opening at The Los Angeles Philharmonic Auditorium.
April 21, 1952: Judy arrives at the star-studded post-party celebrating her opening at The Los Angeles Philharmonic.

Bill Biss: It was a great privilege to read the book and it was a great privilege for you both to reach out to me to talk about “Judy and I.”

John Kimble: You know, Bill. When we met you down in San Diego, it’s rare to find people who want to interview Joe or talk about his mother, in the way it effected them. When you said, “their body of work.” I know in today’s world, we’re not dumb. We know people who like to sensational all that stuff. It’s so disheartening when all that happens. “Meet Me in St. Louis,” Easter Parade, The Wizard of Oz, A Star is Born, Judgement at Nuremberg and The Clock. How do you never talk about that?

Bill Biss: Right.

John Kimble: It doesn’t make sense to me. I don’t think it makes sense to Joey. That is incredible. Her and Mickey Rooney; the money they made built MGM. Isn’t that a better story, sometimes?

Bill Biss: Oh yeah. It’s a tremendous body of work. It was work. It was tremendous pressure. You simply don’t find talent of her caliber that is this long-lasting.

Joey Luft: Yep, I know.

Bill Biss: I think that wraps it up. It’s only four years until what would have been Judy Garland’s 100th birthday. So, start planning!

Yes, I know. Thank you, Bill (Laughter).

© 2017  Bill Biss, The Judy Room & Judy Garland News & Events

Judy Garland, flanked by her daughter Lorna Luft and son Joe Luft, outside The Palace Theater in New York, 1967
Judy Garland, flanked by her daughter Lorna Luft and son Joe Luft, outside The Palace Theater in New York, 1967



  1. I had read long ago that Sid Luft was writing an autobiography, so I was very happy that it was found and completed. All us Judy fans are very interested in his impressions on Judy. His reputation is so controversial, but he was such a large part of Judy’s story. It can’t be told without talking about his influence on her career, which was substantial when you think that it was him that got her started on her spectacular concert career. I got my first Judy Garland (At Carnegie Hall – not a bad start!) when I was in third grade. Fifty four years later (Yikes!), I have something like 250 albums, and I believe all the hard cover biographies. My interest in show biz starts and ends with Judy. I’m very excited to read Sid’s story. Mike B.

  2. What a fool this intelligent, witty, talented lady was regarding her love life. She needed a strong man, yes, but one with skills, money, and a career of his own. Someone who could take care of her financially and take the burden off her. Husband as employee almost never works out, as Doris Day, Shirley MacLaine, and Carol Channing also found out.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.