“She’s very vague about business matters.”
– Judge Burke, Los Angeles, 1952
May 15, 1935: Judy and her sisters, as “The Garland Sisters,” opened a three-week engagement at the Paramount Theater in Los Angeles. The only known photograph of Judy and her sisters in performance on stage was taken during this engagement, as was this snapshot of the marquee. The engagement garnered Judy her sixth “Variety” review: Class act on bill is the Three Garland Sisters, which, for the Paramount booking seems to have concentrated heavily on Francis (sic) the youthful member of the family. Girls do only a couple of harmony numbers, leaving the rest of the perormance to kid sister, who is talented beyond doubt, and who scores heavily with her rendition of “Eili, Eili” plus a couple of songs in foreign tongue.
Another critic said that Judy (still going by Frances) was “about as talented an entertainer as one could imagine.”
May 15, 1939: Another prerecording session for Babes in Arms. Judy, Mickey Rooney, and Betty Jaynes, completed “Good Morning”; “Opera vs. Jazz”; and “Where or When.” There was also filming on the “Interior Moran Living Room” set. Judy had a 9 a.m. call. Per the assistant director’s notes: “9:00-9:17 – wait for Judy Garland – she arrived on set 9 a.m.; but was putting on wardrobe. Meantime, rehearse without Judy; 9:17-9:20 – wait for Judy Garland; lunch was 12:07-1:07; time dismissed: 6 p.m.”
May 15, 1940: Judy was at the MGM portrait studio, posing for glamour portraits with the studio’s famed photographer Eric Carpenter.
May 15, 1945: The production notes for “The Harvey Girls” note: “At 2:30 this morning Judy Garland called Griffin, second assistant on the picture, and told him that she hadn’t slept all night so far because she was making Decca records until 11:45 p.m. last night. She said that after she came home she wasn’t able to sleep and knew that she wouldn’t look good the next day, and since the scene was an important one she felt she better stay home today . . . She called up as she knew we had people ordered and could cancel before it was too late. People were canceled on quarter checks and company was forced to layoff for the day as there are no scenes we could do without her.”
Judy was apparently conserving her strength and voice as she had another recording session with Decca Records that night from 8 p.m. to 11 p.m., the second of three sessions to complete the “Harvey Girls” cast album. Judy recorded the elaborate studio recreation of “On The Atchison, Topeka, And The Santa Fe” which took up two sides of one 78 rpm record.
As noted yesterday, when the album was released, “March of the Doagies” was not included as it was deleted from the film. The removal of the song from the Decca album created an uneven number of sides for the album. The intent was to have four discs with eight songs.
Decca remedied this by having Judy come in and re-record “On The Atchison, Topeka, and the Santa Fe” on September 10, 1945. The number (as recorded on this date in 1945) had originally taken up one disc (two sides) with a recreation of the elaborate introduction by the chorus on the first side (as it is in the film), then Judy’s entrance into the song beginning on the flip side of the disc with her singing the intro “What a lovely trip…” Decca had Judy re-record the song because they deleted that full chorus introduction, so “What a lovely trip” didn’t make sense. The re-recording had Judy singing “What a lovely day.” The final album featured only three discs with six songs.
“March of the Doagies” was not released until November 12, 1984, when it was included on the “From The Decca Vaults” LP.
To confuse things even more, when Decca began re-releasing Judy’s recordings in the LP era, they mistakenly released the original “What a lovely trip…” version of “On The Atchison, Topeka, and the Santa Fe.” The later re-recording (“What a lovely day”) had its LP debut on that same 1984 “From The Decca Vaults” LP.
May 15, 1948: The “Australian Women’s Weekly” published this photo of Judy and costar Gladys Cooper in The Pirate.
May 15, 1952: Judy was two hours late for a required court appearance in Los Angeles. Her failure to show up on time resulted in a bench warrant being issued for her arrest. Luckily she wasn’t actually arrested. Judy was required to testify in the suit filed on May 6, in which Sid Luft’s former wife, actress Lynn Bari, was seeking more money for the support of their son, John Michael Luft, specifically asking for an increase from $200 to $400 a month. Bari wanted a piece of Judy’s recent concert earnings of which she was sure Sid was enjoying. Judy explained that she was late because her attorney, Robert B. Agins, told her she didn’t need to appear until she was called in via telephone.
During the proceedings, it was disclosed that Sid paid $4,329.25 for the care of his three race horses, worth $16,500, but only paid $3,600 in child support.
Judy testified that there was no written agreement under which she employed Sid (as her “advisor”) paying him $450 to $500 a week and that he was able to draw on her “production enterprises” for “anything he needs.” After all of that, the hearing was adjourned until May 29 after Bari’s lawyers asked that Judy’s records of Sid’s salary be produced in court. That court date never happened.
On June 11th Sid was ordered to increase the weekly amount from $200 to $400 and to pay $750 for fees to Bari’s lawyer, S.S. Hahn. The $400 to Bari broke down as follows: $200 a month for a governess, $75 a month for rent, $50 a month for nursery school, $50 a month for food, and $25 a month for clothing.
In the interim Judy opened a month-long engagement at San Francisco’s Curran Theater and on June 8th she and Sid were married.
Sid failed to reveal the marriage at the June 11th hearing, so on June 12th Hahn threatened another lawsuit demanding an increase to $1,000 per month because of his failure to disclose.
Apparently, the proceedings were not very civil. Bari accused Sid of being deceitful in hiding his recent marriage to Judy. Hahn asked the court to hold Sid in contempt for withholding that information. “He deceived the court as to his financial standing,” Hahn said. “Luft pleaded he was paid only $500 a week by Miss Garland to act as her manager. He is now at least half a millionaire. Under California law, her earnings become half his because of community property statutes.” Hahn also called Sid’s behavior “deliberated concealment of his financial condition.”
According to the L.A. Times:
Hahn also commented on the testimony given last month by Miss Garland. He declared she “parroted” luft’s statements and called her “a little Charley [sic] McCarthy.”
“This girl gives him all her money,” said Hahn. “He can write as much of a check as he wants, judge. He takes anything he wants that she has.”
Judge Burke commented that he thought Miss Garland had been an honest witness but said, “She’s very vague about business matters.”
Hahn talked of the manner in which Luft lives, declaring: “He lives high. Sure. Like people in Hollywood do. Live high. End up in the street later. But until he ends up in the street, this child should be cared for.”
The case wasn’t settled until six days later on June 17th at which time Sid and Bari came to an agreement on a sum, the amount is unknown but it was probably that $400 plus $600 to make that requested $1,000. It was reported that a trust would be set up for the boy, which is probably where that $600 difference went.
Meanwhile, up in San Francisco, Judy was performing to sellout crowds.
May 15, 1953: Both Louella Parsons and Sheilah Graham reported on Judy’s return from the South. Judy took part in the recent Blue Grass Festival in Lexington, Kentucky, then she spent time in Sulphur Springs (Alabama?) where, according to Louella, she lost 22 pounds in anticipation of starting production/filming on A Star Is Born. That’s a lot to lose in just two weeks time! Graham reported that Judy and husband Sid Luft arrived back in Los Angeles on this day “from the Greenbriars in Virginny.” It’s unclear just exactly where Judy and Sid returned from.
Production on A Star Is Born officially started on August 18, 1953.
May 15, 1966: Judy attended the “Tribute to Judy Holiday/Cancer Benefit for The American Center in Denver” held at the Americana Hotel in New York City. Judy had flown to New York the previous day specifically to attend this event. She sang: “When you’re Smiling”; “Rock-A-Bye Your Baby”; “Just In Time”; “The Party’s Over”; and encored with “You Mabe Me Love You”/”For Me And My Gal”/”The Trolley Song” and “Over The Rainbow.”
The photo above was taken at the event. Judy is seen with Betty Comden and Adolph Green.
May 15, 1967: “A Funny Thing Happened On The Way To Hollywood” aired on NBC-TV. This Jack Paar special was videotaped in color on May 7, 1967, although only a B&W film print survives. The show was taped at NBC’s Rockefeller Center, Studio 6B, in New York City.
On the day of taping, Judy was escorted by Sid Luft and Tom Green. She arrived at 6:20 p.m.; the taping started at 8 p.m. Judy is in good form but not sounding or looking very well. Several stories that Judy told were cut from the show: Judy told the story of Elvis pulling up in his car only a week before the taping to say he was a big fan, but ignoring Paar who was in the car with Judy; A “recreation” of her dance down the yellow brick road; “The time she sang “God Bless America” on stage with a model who was made up as The Statue of Liberty but was so plastered she fell flat on her face while Judy was trying to sing the song!