On This Day In Judy Garland’s Life And Career – September 16

Posted by

“When the performance was over and Judy had left the stage for good, thousands of people were standing and staring at the stage, numb from the impact of a little girl with big brown eyes who had finished the greatest performance I have ever seen in my life.” – Eddie Sherman, review of Judy Garland at the Hollywood Bowl, 1961

September 16, 1935:  MGM issued the order to their legal department to prepare a contract “for the services of Judy Garland as an actress.”  The contract spanned seven years beginning on October 1, 1935, and called for an initial salary of $100.00 a week, with options every six months for the first year, then once a year for the remaining six years.  It was a standard contract, and the options meant the studio could drop her if they chose.

Judy’s birth date is given as January 10, 1923, six months after her real birth date which was June 10, 1922.  It was most likely an attempt to make her seem even younger than she already was.  The contract also allowed Judy to negotiate for radio performances, with MGM’s consent.


September 16, 1936:  Judy and Deanna Durbin were filming their first official film for MGM, the short subject Every Sunday.  I say “official” because the year before Judy and her sisters had actually appeared in an MGM short, La Fiesta De Santa Barbara which predated Judy’s becoming an MGM contract player.  On this day, they were photographed on the MGM backlot with Patricia Palmer.


Also on this day, the trade paper “Film Daily” ran this blurb that Judy had signed a new long-term contract.  A year prior (see above) she had signed a standard contract with MGM.  There are no records of any second contract.  It might have been a standard six-month renewal that they’re referencing.  Judy’s contract wasn’t rewritten until September 1940.

For more info about Judy Garland’s appearances in short subjects, check out The Judy Room’s Filmography Sections “Shorts” page here.

The Film Daily

September 16, 1937:  This notice promoting Broadway Melody of 1938, and other MGM films, appeared in the “Film Daily” trade paper.

Check out The Judy Room’s Filmography Page on Broadway Melody of 1938 here.

September 16, 1938:  Judy pre-recorded “Zing! Went The Strings Of My Heart” for the film Listen Darling.   Takes 4, 6, 9, 10, 14 & 15 were “printed” (kept for use in deciding which take to use and/or use it as part or all of the final mix for the film).  The long takes are the ballad versions.  The song was filmed six days later and trimmed quite a bit for the final edit.

Judy sang “Zing!” as part of her audition for MGM on September 13, 1935, and it stayed in her repertoire through the end of her life.

Listen to a few of the prerecordings here:

Ballad version take 15:

Ballad version tag take 1:

Swing version take 4:

Swing version tag take 4:

Final ballad version here:

Final swing version here:

Judy recorded two versions, one ballad and one with a “swing” midsection.  Those pre-recordings were originally released on the 1995 LaserDisc double feature of “Thoroughbreds Don’t Cry/Listen, Darling.”

The complete ballad version was originally released on the 1995 6-CD set “That’s Entertainment! The Ultimate Anthology of M-G-M Musicals” and the 2006 re-release.   Those two sets were the only CD source for this ballad version until the 2017 CD set “Soundtracks” in which it’s remastered and sounding better than ever.

The complete swing version was released on CD in 1996 on the “Collector’s Gems” 2-disc set.  It has since been re-released on various bootleg CDs such as the 1999 Spanish bootleg CD which featured copies of the Rhino tracks and the 2000 German bootleg “The Sound of the Movies” series.

The swing version was expertly remastered and released on the 2014 5-CD set “Judy Garland – The Garland Variations.”

Check out The Judy Room’s Filmography Page on Listen Darling here.

Check out the video below that presents the full-swing version as it might have been in the film.  In stereo!  The video was created by our friend Mark Milano.  Check out his channel for more Garland treats!

Below: Detroit ad for a local showing of Love Finds Andy Hardy.

September 16, 1939:  More Wizard of Oz blurbs as published in the various industry trade magazines.

September 16, 1939:  This “Lion’s Roar” banner and one-page article were published in the “Australian Women’s Weekly” newspaper.  The article is about the current Hollywood teen set and how they have parties.

September 16, 1942:  This photo was taken of Judy on the set of Presenting Lily Mars.

Check out The Judy Room’s Extensive Spotlight Section on Presenting Lily Mars here.

September 16, 1943:  The “Hollywood Cavalcade” of stars arrived in Chicago, Illinois, from Cincinnati, Ohio, as part of the War Bond drive, raising money for the war effort by selling war bonds.  The second image above features a photo of Judy taken the previous night at the festivities in Cincinnati.

At this time, Judy’s latest film, Presenting Lily Mars, was a big success with audiences and critics, even if the review above lists Judy’s co-star as Van Johnson and not Van Heflin!

Check out The Judy Room’s Spotlight on Presenting Lily Mars here.

September 16, 1943:  Here’s an article written by columnist Inga Arvad, published in the “Miami Daily News,” that mentioned upcoming films to be produced by MGM producer Arthur Freed.  It mentions Meet Me In St. Louis with Van Johnson to co-star with Judy (in the role that eventually went to Tom Drake), as well as Ziegfeld Follies and The Pirate.  At this point, it’s noted that the stars of the original stage version, Lynn Fontanne and Alfred Lunt, were offered the lead roles.

September 16, 1943:  Ad for Thousands Cheer as published in the trade magazine Film Daily.

September 16, 1944:  Here is an example of local theatre displays, this time for Thousands Cheer (released in 1943), being shown in Phoenix, Arizona.

Judy Garland Robert Walker The Clock

September 16, 1944:  Filming on The Clock continued with scenes shot on the “Interior Penn Station (Lobby and Stairs) set.  Time called: 10 a.m.; time dismissed: 5:50 p.m.

Check out The Judy Room’s Filmography Pages on The Clock here.

September 16, 1948:  Here is another trade ad placed by MGM in the trade magazine “Film Daily.”  Easter Parade and Words and Music are two of the films noted.

September 16, 1950:  Judy was in the news.

First up is a review of Summer Stock from Hanover, Pennsylvania

Columnist Herb Rau relayed a story about the “curvaceous” performer Francine Zarra rudely remarking about gaining some weight, “But I’m not too worried about my weight, I just saw Judy Garland in ‘Summer Stock’, and I don’t think the extra pounds show on me as much as on her.”  Ouch!

Hedda Hopper told the story about Judy and her husband Vincente Minnelli going backstage after seeing Laurette Taylor in “The Glass Menagerie.”  Taylor, who to this day is considered one of the greatest actresses ever to grace the stage, told Judy, “You have the greatest talent ever wrapped up in one little package.”  Judy was elated.

A quick blurb about Judy going to see herself in Summer Stock while in New York and calling the film’s producer, Joe Pasternak, about it.

Check out The Judy Room’s Filmography Page on Summer Stock here.

September 16, 1950:  The bottom of this ad notes that the short film Moments in Music will be accompanying the main feature at this theatre in Dunkirk, New York.

Check out The Judy Room’s “Judy Garland Shorts” Page for details about the shorts that Judy appeared in.

September 16, 1954:  The news broke that Judy was expecting a third child.  According to Louella Parsons, Judy found out on this date but that’s highly unlikely.  Judy’s third child and only son, Joe Luft, was born on March 29, 1955.

September 16, 1955:  Judy’s upcoming TV debut (September 24, 1955) was news.

Check out The Judy Room’s “Judy Garland – The Concert Years” here.

September 16, 1956:  Judy’s return to the Palace Theater, September 26.

Check out The Judy Room’s “Judy Garland – The Concert Years” here.

September 16, 1956:  The first installment of a five-part series about Judy written by columnist Joe Hyams.

Check out The Judy Room’s “Judy Garland – The Concert Years” here.

September 16, 1957:  Judy was in concert at Loew’s Capitol Theatre in Washington, D.C.  This was Judy’s first concert after taking most of the summer off after her “Vegas tour” ended.  “Variety” noted: “This is a different kind of theatrical engagement.  It’s a love affair between Judy Garland and the folks who are paying up to a $6.60 top this week, to hear her sing at the Capitol Theatre here.  Miss Garland makes a quick rapport with her audience, and you can feel the affection they have for her from the time she opens up with her big, deep voice.”

Some color silent home movie footage taken from the audience during the Saturday matinee exists and features Judy bringing daughter Lorna and son Joey up on the stage.  Judy sang “Rock-A-Bye Your Baby” to Lorna since, as Judy claimed, “Lorna likes the loud ones,” and “Happiness Is A Thing Called Joe” with Joey on her lap.

Judy’s last night of the engagement was September 21st.  The final night was scheduled to be the 22nd but she came down with the Asian Flu and developed a temperature of 103 degrees.

Check out The Judy Room’s “Judy Garland – The Concert Years” here.

September 16, 1961:  During the day, Judy attended a private screening of Judgment at Nuremberg, which is the first time she saw the film.

Check out The Judy Room’s Filmography Page on Judgment at Nuremberg here.

That night, Judy took her Carnegie Hall concert to The Hollywood Bowl in Los Angeles.  This version included “Never Will I Marry,” “Oh, What A Little Moonlight Can Do,” and “Just In Time,” keeping her Carnegie Hall program fresh for herself and her audience.  The show broke the Bowl’s box office record.  It grossed $72,412.  Judy was guaranteed $25,000 against a percentage, which made her take-home pay $30,000.   17,823 people were in attendance (a full house), who refused to leave even during a heavy downpour of rain.  After the show, 1,000 people waited backstage to see Judy before she left for supper at Romanoff’s.

According to Eddie Sherman’s column, Judy was given an ovation when she entered the restaurant.  He noted that “a well-known Hollywood columnist sitting in front of Judy’s sister during the concert thought the sister was a bit too demonstrative.  The writer was silenced with: ‘Where were  you when Judy needed you?'”

Scan of the program was provided by Bobby Waters.  Thanks, Bobby!

Check out The Judy Room’s “Judy Garland – The Concert Years” here.

Photo of the program cover (above left) provided by Bobby Waters.  Thanks, Bobby!

September 16, 1963:  Judy took a break from rehearsals for the next episode of “The Judy Garland Show” to announce, along with June Allyson and Carolyn Jones, the creation of a Birmingham Children’s Fund of Beverly Hills.  The fund was set up to raise money to help the victims of the recent horrific bombing of the 16th Street Baptist Church on September 15th by white supremacists in Birmingham, Alabama, which killed four innocent young girls.

Check out The Judy Room’s “Judy Garland – The Concert Years” here.

September 16, 1965:  Here is a ticket to Judy’s concert at the Greek Theatre in Los Angeles, California.  Judy opened at the theatre on September 13th.  Ticket image is provided by Bobby Waters.  Thanks, Bobby!

Check out The Judy Room’s “Judy Garland – The Concert Years” here.

September 16, 2013:  “Time” magazine published a special edition of “Life” magazine devoted to the 75th anniversary of The Wizard of Oz titled “The Wizard of Oz: 75 Years Along the Yellow Brick Road.”  Featured online was this five-part series by Richard Corliss which was adapted from an essay in the magazine which hit newsstands that week.

Click here to read and download the complete PDF of all five installments here.

Check out The Judy Room’s Spotlight on The Wizard of Oz here.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.